Is It Better To Use a CPA Or Accountant?

As a business owner, choosing between a CPA and an accountant can feel like a pivotal decision. Whether you’re running a small startup or scaling a high-growth enterprise, understanding the difference between these two roles is crucial for your financial success. Do you need someone to handle day-to-day bookkeeping, or are you looking for expert advice on complex tax strategies and audits? Knowing the strengths and limitations of both CPAs and accountants will empower you to make the best choice for your business needs—and potentially save you time, money, and headaches down the road. Understanding the differences in roles and competencies, especially in the context of accounting services for small businesses, is vital for making an informed choice.

CPA vs Accountant: Definition and Roles

A CPA (Certified Public Accountant) is a highly credentialed financial professional who has passed the rigorous CPA exam and met stringent state certification requirements, which often include a combination of education, experience, and ethics standards. In addition to these qualifications, CPAs are required to maintain their certification through ongoing education to stay current with evolving tax laws and accounting practices. This elevated status allows CPAs to perform a wide range of specialized tasks that non-certified accountants cannot legally undertake. Some of these tasks include conducting external audits, representing clients before the IRS, and providing expert opinions in legal settings, such as court testimonies or regulatory investigations.

CPAs are held to a higher standard of accountability and are subject to more stringent ethical regulations, governed by state boards of accountancy. Because of their certified status, they are often sought after for complex financial tasks like forensic accounting, strategic financial planning, and advanced tax consulting. This qualification is also crucial for those looking to work with publicly traded companies, as the SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission) requires that all financial statements be audited by a CPA.

In contrast, an accountant may have a degree in accounting and can handle a broad range of general financial responsibilities. Accountants are typically involved in activities like bookkeeping, preparing financial statements, and conducting routine tax filings. They play a crucial role in helping businesses and individuals maintain organized and accurate financial records. However, unlike CPAs, accountants are not required to meet the same rigorous certification standards, nor do they have the legal authority to perform audits, represent clients in disputes with tax authorities, or provide certain advisory services that require certification.

While both CPAs and accountants are essential to the financial health of individuals and organizations, the distinction between the two lies in the complexity of the tasks they can perform and the legal protections their certifications afford them. Many businesses may choose to employ accountants for day-to-day financial operations but turn to CPAs for more specialized and legally required financial tasks, particularly during tax season, audits, or when complex regulatory issues arise.

Situations Where a CPA May Be Preferable

When dealing with complex financial needs, such as business audits, intricate tax planning, or financial reporting for publicly traded companies, a CPA is often the preferable choice, but should a small business have a CPA? CPAs have rigorous training and are up-to-date on the latest financial regulations and changes in tax laws, which can benefit high-growth businesses and ensure compliance with all legal requirements.

Instances Where an Accountant Might Suffice

For less complex financial tasks, an accountant without CPA certification can be entirely sufficient. Routine bookkeeping, everyday accounting, and general tax preparation do not necessarily require the advanced skills of a CPA. If your business is a startup or in its early stages of growth, hiring a well-qualified accountant can be both effective and economical.

Cost Considerations

Budget is an important factor. Typically, services provided by a CPA come at a higher cost due to their specialized skills and certifications. An accountant might be a more cost-effective solution for businesses that do not need high-level financial services. It’s essential to balance your business needs with your financial limitations to choose the appropriate professional.

In conclusion, determining whether to hire a CPA or an accountant hinges on the complexity of your financial needs, your budget, and your business goals. Understanding their different roles and the specific situations where each excels will guide you in making the best decision for your enterprise’s success. Here is more about how much does a CPA cost per month?

What Can a CPA Do That an Accountant Cannot?

Businesses often find themselves asking, “What can a CPA do that an accountant cannot?” Understanding the key differences in their roles and capabilities can guide you in making the right choice for your organization.

Regulatory Authority and Certifications

One of the most significant differences between a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) and a non-certified accountant is the level of regulatory authority and certification. A CPA is licensed and regulated by state boards, ensuring they meet stringent qualifications and adhere to a Code of Professional Conduct. They must pass the Uniform CPA Examination and meet state-specific experience and education requirements.

Audit and Assurance Services

Only CPAs are authorized to perform audit and assurance services. This includes the evaluation of financial statements and providing an opinion on their accuracy based on a thorough review. These services are crucial for businesses that require external validation of their financials, especially publicly traded companies.

Representation Before the IRS

Another crucial function that differentiates a CPA from an accountant is the ability to represent clients before the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). While accountants can prepare and file tax returns, only CPAs, enrolled agents, and attorneys have the legal authority to represent a client in IRS audits, collections, and appeals.

Advanced Specializations

CPAs often possess specialized knowledge in areas such as tax consultancy, forensic accounting, business valuations, and financial planning. They can offer more in-depth, strategic advice to help businesses navigate complex financial scenarios. This could include tax planning strategies to optimize liabilities, financial analysis for mergers and acquisitions, or meticulous forensic accounting to detect fraud.

Choosing between a CPA and an accountant should be based on the specific needs and complexities of your business. For high-stakes financial decisions, audit services, or IRS issues, a CPA’s advanced skills and legal authority make them the preferable choice.

Is a CPA Really Necessary?

Deciding whether a CPA is really necessary for your business or personal financial needs can be a complex decision. It’s crucial to consider various factors such as the complexity of your financial situation, what services you need, and your budget. There are online CPA services for small business that may be more cost efficient.

When It’s Critical to Hire a CPA

There are certain circumstances where hiring a CPA is non-negotiable. If your business is facing an audit, requires accurate financial reporting to stakeholders, or needs someone to represent you before the IRS, a CPA is indispensable. CPAs have specific training and certifications that allow them to perform audits and assurance services. They are also well-versed in tax law and can offer valuable insights to optimize your tax situation.

When an Accountant Without CPA May Be Adequate

Not every financial situation necessitates the expertise of a CPA. In less complex scenarios, such as simple bookkeeping, preparing budget reports, or handling routine tax filings, a standard accountant can be entirely sufficient. This is particularly the case if your business is small or in the early stages of growth.

Cost-Effectiveness of Hiring a CPA vs Accountant

Cost is a significant consideration when deciding between a CPA and an accountant. While CPAs typically command higher fees due to their advanced qualifications and capabilities, this cost can be justified if your financial needs are complex and demand specialized knowledge. On the other hand, an accountant’s services might be more affordable and still adequate for simpler financial tasks.

Importance of Qualifications and Experience

The qualifications and experience of your financial advisor should be a primary factor in your decision. A CPA has undergone rigorous training and passed stringent exams, ensuring a high level of expertise. Conversely, an accountant may have varied levels of training and experience, so it’s crucial to verify their credentials and track record. Ultimately, the right choice will depend on the specific needs of your business and your comfort level with the professional’s capabilities.

In conclusion, whether to hire a CPA or an accountant depends largely on the complexity of your financial situation and the specific tasks you need help with. Carefully evaluate your needs and budget to make the most informed decision.

Do CPAs Make More Money Than Accountants?

The question of whether CPAs make more money than accountants is a common one among business owners and aspiring finance professionals. Generally, you’ll find that CPAs tend to command higher salaries when compared to accountants who do not hold the CPA designation. Let’s dive deeper into the factors behind these differences to help you make an informed decision.

Average Salary Comparison

According to various salary surveys and industry reports, the average salary for a CPA is generally higher than that of an accountant without a CPA designation. For instance, data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and industry-specific studies suggest that CPAs can earn anywhere from 10% to 20% more than their non-CPA counterparts. This pay premium is largely due to the specialized skills and regulatory authority that come with the CPA credential.

Factors Influencing Salary Differences

There are several factors that contribute to the salary differences between CPAs and accountants. These include:

Educational Background and Certifications

CPAs have to undergo rigorous educational requirements, including passing the CPA exam and obtaining continuing education credits. These qualifications make them more valuable in the eyes of employers.

Roles and Responsibilities

Due to their specialized skills, CPAs often take on more complex and higher-stakes responsibilities, such as audits, forensic accounting, and tax strategy. These roles come with higher compensation.

Career Growth and Earning Potential

An important aspect to consider is the long-term career growth and earning potential. CPAs have a distinct edge when it comes to climbing the career ladder. The CPA designation opens up opportunities for managerial and executive roles, which offer significantly higher salaries and benefits. Additionally, CPAs who enter specialized fields such as forensic accounting, consulting, or tax advisory can command even higher rates.

Geographic Location and Its Impact

Your geographic location can also play a significant role in determining salaries. In metropolitan areas and regions with a high cost of living, both accountants and CPAs tend to earn more. However, the salary gap between CPAs and non-CPAs remains consistent across different locations, as the CPA designation is highly valued nationwide.

Elevate your financial strategy with Milestone’s team of experts. Our unparalleled expertise in accounting, HR, and payroll services can transform your back office into a competitive advantage, allowing you to focus on growth and high-value activities. Partner with Milestone to achieve your business goals with confidence and precision. Reach out to the Milestone team today!